Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Is Ender's Game science fiction?

I think, of all the stories I've addressed so far, Ender's Game, by Orson Scott Card, is more science fiction than any other. This applies from a classical-definition-of-science-fiction standpoint (it's a book about alien invasions in the future with spaceships and stuff), and from the standpoint of my own definition of science fiction, for reasons that I'll talk about in a paragraph or two. What makes Ender's Game most notable, however, is how elegantly it's able to represent the way in which science fiction's proclivity for the former enables it to clearly convey the latter.


In my opinion, Ender's Game represents one of the most comprehensive studies of morality (in particular, the moral laws that govern the use/abuse of power by authority figures) that has ever been written into fiction. However, the plot that sustains this fascinating philosophical exercise is, on its surface, utterly sophomoric. Ender Wiggin, a child of six, is inducted by the military into "Battle School," a place for children like him to be trained into the generals that will fight off a potential invasion by the "Buggers," a race of violent, insect-like aliens. As Gerald Jonas wrote in his (very positive) review of the book for the New York Times, it "sounds like the synopsis of a grade Z, made-for-television, science-fiction-rip-off movie."

And it's certainly true. But Ender's Game uses this plot to great effect. At Battle School, Ender confronts a series of games, from the virtual reality game on the school's PCs to the book's famous zero-gravity laser tag to the final command simulator. And yet, none of them are really games. Ender is too young and naïve to realize it, but every moment of his life, from his birth to his final battle against the Buggers, has been planned out. He is being manipulated constantly by the adults in his life, Colonel Graff in particular, being crafted into a weapon that the military can literally use however they please. At the novel's end, Ender completely wipes out the Buggers, but does not even learn that he has been fighting them until the final battle is over. Upon learning what he has done, Ender is wracked with overwhelming guilt, and rightfully so; he suddenly realizes that he has the blood of billions of lives on his hands.

Which has to make you wonder: To what extent, if any, is Ender responsible for the extermination of the buggers? To what extent can you hold Colonel Graff responsible? Ender's Game certainly points out the power that authority figures have. Teachers and parents have the ability to mold and shape children into any number of things. There is no doubt that parents and teachers have a responsibility to use that power, but Ender's Game makes something else clear: That power, like any other, can be used morally or immorally, for good or for evil.


There's another question, though, that is equally important in thinking about the morality of Ender's Game: The Buggers had attacked Earth twice before, and all attempts to communicate with them had failed; was their extermination even morally wrong? Is there anything that fundamentally separates them from cockroaches, or killing them from killing cockroaches? This is a particularly interesting question when viewed in the context of the recent widely-publicized comments by Stephen Hawking on this very subject. "If aliens visit us," he said, "the outcome would be much as when Columbus landed in America, which didn't turn out well for the Native Americans." To assess the potential validity of that statement, I would have to look towards human beings for a baseline: How would we act if we came upon an alien race? I'd like to think that we'd study them, and interact with them, but never exterminate them. But violent action against any species that is not human is incredibly easy for us to morally justify, and that gives me pause.

These are all crucial questions to be asking, in my opinion, but these sorts of questions cannot be asked except through science fiction conventions. How do you explore the implications of wiping out an intelligent but non-human race without aliens? How do you turn Ender into such powerful yet naïve weapon (and explore the questions that result from such a scenario) without the kinds of high-tech games that Ender's Game describes? I simply cannot see a way to explore these scenarios or ask these questions except through science fiction and its various conventions.


Finally, however, Ender's Game is remarkable for one reason that is completely unrelated to my conception of what science fiction should be: It had an eerily prescient view of the future. Science fiction has always made a name for itself in predicting the future of our society, many times by predicting the technology that will later be invented. The submarine in 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea did exactly that, as did the water beds that appeared in several of Robert Heinlein's books (Heinlein's detailed descriptions of water beds made them impossible to patent once someone finally invented a working one). You might say that Ender's Game accomplished this feat by describing laptop computers with advanced GUIs (called "desks" in the novel); more importantly, however, Orson Scott Card predicted how we would use them.

Ender's Game was published in 1985, long after the invention of the PC and the internet, but long before either of them had risen to prominence in society. Yet the characters in the novel use them to perform a wide array of unmistakably modern activities: web browsing, emailing, and, most importantly, blogging. Orson Scott Card was able to conceive of a future in which two children (Ender's siblings) use their parents' computer to set up and write blogs that then become enormously influential—mainly because their readers have no idea they're children. This may not seem very impressive, but consider this: The novel existed five years before the first website was created, five years before the first commercial internet service provider went into business, and ten years before the first blog was created. Orson Scott Card had a conception of the social importance of the internet far beyond that of any of his contemporaries in academics or fiction, and, quite frankly, I don't think he could have done that without science fiction either.

46 comments:

Dana Watkins said...

What's a GUI? And BTW, I'm glad you cited Stephen Hawking's recent comments on aliens, because I was very interested in getting your reaction to them.

rajuhasan2222 said...



Need Notebooks go my website

Unknown said...

Know about best sport supplements go my website

nelaakter24 said...

Need poker go my website.i hope you don't unlike.!


Unknown said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

East Grinstead Accountants

Unknown said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

East Grinstead Accountants

Unknown said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Crawley

Unknown said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

East Grinstead Accountants

Accountants Redhill said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Crawley

Capital Gains Tax advice said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Lingfield

Capital Gains Tax advice said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Lingfield

Unknown said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns,Company and Corporation Tax advice,Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money,reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services :http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Lingfield

Unknown said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns,Company and Corporation Tax advice,Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money,reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services :http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Lingfield

Accountants Redhill said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Haywards Heath

Capital Gains Tax advice said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Horley

Unknown said...

V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors and Chartered Certified Accountants, represent an authoritative source on most aspects of tax and specialise in the following: Self-Assessment Tax advice, Self Employed Tax Returns, Company and Corporation Tax advice, Capital Gains Tax advice, Buy-To-Let Property Tax advice, Tax Planning and Tax Consultancy Services. With over 25 years of experience in the business of providing expert tax advice, V P Associates Chartered Tax Advisors offer valuable information to clients to help them save money, reduce and mitigate tax. V P Associates, Chartered Tax Advisors & Chartered Certified Accountants, are the first and foremost specialists in taxation matters. Visit their site for a comprehensive list of services: http://vpassociates.com/

Accountants Horley

monalisa said...

Go uptu.ac.in and get many information just

monalisa said...

Get letest happy new year 2016 improtant element go our website

Unknown said...

Need seo service agency go our website

raju247 said...

Lake Grande MCL Land near Lakeside MRT. Latest Top Tender Bid in Jurong West Street 41 Site.

Unknown said...

online press release distribution helps you create buzz, increase online visibility and drive website traffic.

nann said...

UltimateNutritionz We recommend sports and nutrition supplements based on feedback, side effects and the ability to actually Guid.Know more please go our website.

Unknown said...

Phentermine is one of the most popular anti-obesity drugs consumed highly by Americans these days. But, the question is whether Phentermine “the solution” for weight loss?

nann said...

Let me warn you up front - virtually every lottery system out there is total junk. So be prepared for some honest ”lottery review.know more just go our website…

raju247 said...

PeopleLookup People Search Find the person you're looking for by name, phone number or address. People search on YP with the white pages is fast and simple.

Anonymous said...

Find pressure washing tampa Services?. Read Ratings and Reviews on Tampa Pressure Washing Services on Angie's List so you can pick the right Pressure …KNOW MORE JUST GO OUR WEBSITE..

Tax Advisors said...

This is an online e-commerce website where customers can purchase mid to high-range fitness accessories, apparel and nutritional supplements. Our incredible team developed this e-commerce website to showcase different categories of apparel, accessories and supplements to promote ease-of-access to our customers. We offer quality products designed for results oriented and effective workout. Even when you're not working out, we have other products and accessories to keep you looking your best and staying motivated.

Lastly, I started "Workout or Walkout" after I said similar words to someone in a gym one day when I got tired of people spending more time on their phones than they actually spend working out in the gym. I love and encourage phones in the gym for many reasons but if I need to use an equipment and it's not available simply because you choose to use it as a couch to text or chat, then we have a tiny bit of a problem my friend. Workout, Eat healthy; it's a lifetime thing! #workoutorwalkout #stayhealthymyfriends

For more information please click at anti-bacterial towel

Gchopra62 said...


HTET Online Board of School Education Haryana (BSEH) will declare the result of HTET in January 2018.

Hero said...

1xbet turkiye 1xbet Türkiye, online bahis şirketi hakkında giriş ve inceleme bilgileri. Onebahis firması için 2020 güncel yeni giriş adresi, ödemeler ve üyelik işlemleri için detaylı bilgiler, 1xbahis sayfamızda yer almakta.

Rafid said...

top 3 weight loss pills Authentic Option LLC offers collection of natural herbal products for skincare, hair care, and weight loss. We specialize in thermal weight loss, electrostimulation for muscle toning, cellulite removal, under-eye bags treatment and skincare products. We have an amazing range of beard growing products.

Rafid said...

situs judi dominoqq

Receap said...

xanax pill On the other hand, if one is experiencing more chronic and frequent anxiety, they may usually be prescribed Xanax 2mg. This dosage is stronger and helps treat insomnia. This dosage provides

Haider said...

runtz

Mira said...

soi cau xo so mien bac

AR Rahman said...

HORoskop

Hero said...

Ketamine HCL Liquid Vials

,

Ketamine HCL Powder, Special K, Kit Kat

,

Buy 3-MeO-PCP Online,

Buy Ecstasy Online Without Prescription,

Ephedrine HCL Crystals,

Buy MXE Online Buy Methoxetamine Online,

Furanyl Fentanyl Powder

,

A-PVP Crystals,

Acetyl Fentanyl Powder,

Vyvanse (Lisdexamfetamine)

,

Aslam said...

how to download Facebook videos

Rafid said...

Samoyed puppy We have been branded as the best cattery for breeding healthy kittens and puppies ready for a home.

Aslam said...

canim sohbet Android Dear ChatCanım chat is growing day by day with the android chat service it has given to you and serves you, dear chat lovers, free of charge. You can connect and chat online at any time of the day with your smart devices on our chat site. Anonymous chat is a free chat site that allows you to chat randomly and does not charge any fee or money from our valued chat users.

James said...

legitimate online casinos Compare the best legit online casinos that pay real money including the best crypto casinos, best mobile casinos and the best online casinos in 2021

Rafid said...

Magic mushrooms for sale

AR Rahman said...

Handy man management services

James said...

dank vape carts

Aslam said...

motherhood CO.MOM is a fun new online magazine and social network community created by moms for moms. Read interesting articles, get advice from our agony aunt, aunt\y anne, learn how to earn an income online with our guru debbie or you can even seek medical advice from our resident physician dr samantha and relax while checking out the latest horoscopes from our trained mystic. Theres even a thriving forum community where moms of the world can get together and enjoy good conversation along with lots of other fun ways to kill some time with a cuppa when taking a break from being super mom at co.mom.

Company Setup Consultants said...

Do you Know - How to Get a Trade License in Abu Dhabi? Read hear full Steps to register abu dhabi trade license , Trade license cost, activities, cancellation and renewal process and fees.

maevaiannotti said...

Casino in St. Louis: The best casinos near Minneapolis
Minneapolis-St. 군포 출장샵 Paul's Downtown St. Paul 의정부 출장마사지 is the perfect destination for you 여주 출장샵 to stay and 동두천 출장샵 play at the St. Louis Casino, where 안산 출장샵 your favorite games and